 Photo of the first service of The Axis Madison - a partnership between Madison FBC + The Axis Germantown - April 19 I’ve consulted with well over 100 churches. Some of those engagements have gone remarkably well. Others have gone down in glorious flames—the kind that leave you with both head wounds and heartaches. In just the past quarter, I’ve watched two partnerships come together in ways I can only describe as supernatural. In both cases, churches facing uncertain futures were joined with strong, growing congregations that needed permanent space. The result? Not survival—renewal. Not loss—redeployment. So what makes some partnership conversations succeed while others collapse? It’s not strategy. It’s not structure. It’s not even the terms of the deal. It’s the posture of the leaders in the room. Here are the factors that consistently determine whether a church partnership lives or dies. 1. Humility: Telling the Truth About Reality Every healthy partnership begins with honesty. The church facing an uncertain future has to come to terms with something hard: we can’t do this on our own anymore. That’s not failure. That’s clarity. But humility doesn’t stop there. The stronger church must walk in with just as much restraint. If they show up as rescuers, the partnership is already compromised. No one needs a savior complex—there’s already a Savior. Strong churches don’t “take over.” They come alongside. They build on the legacy of faithfulness that’s already there, even if that legacy is fading. When both sides are humble, conversations stay open. When either side isn’t, they shut down fast. 2. Kingdom Vision: Capital “K” vs. Lowercase “k” This is where most partnerships quietly fail. If even one party is trying to preserve their church—their identity, their preferences, their control—then you’re dealing with a lowercase kingdom. And lowercase kingdoms always compete. Healthy partnerships only emerge when everyone in the room settles this question: Is this about our church—or God’s Kingdom? When it becomes about the Kingdom—capital “K”—the conversation shifts.
At that point, decisions get clearer. Not easier—but clearer. 3. Grace: The Currency of Every Partnership Let’s be honest—these conversations are emotionally loaded. For the struggling church, this often feels like loss. The ministry they’ve known is changing. Their role is shifting. In many cases, they’re moving from leading to participating. That requires grace from the stronger church. Patience. Honor. Care in how words are spoken and decisions are made. But grace has to flow both ways. Struggling churches often come into these conversations wounded—and that can turn into suspicion. Motives get questioned. Actions get misread. Every decision feels threatening. Some of that is understandable. But here’s the hard truth: oversensitivity, unrealistic demands, and ultimatums will kill a partnership faster than almost anything else. If a stronger church is arrogant or dismissive—call it out. That’s real. But more often, what derails partnerships isn’t domination—it’s distrust. Grace means refusing to assume the worst when there’s no evidence for it. 4. Prayer: The Missing Ingredient in Failed Partnerships You can tell almost immediately whether a partnership has been prayed over—or just talked through. When prayer is absent, preferences dominate. When prayer is present, something else begins to take shape:
Partnerships don’t work because the terms are perfect. They work because God is at work in the people involved. And that only happens when leaders stop managing outcomes and start seeking the Lord. If a partnership isn’t being bathed in prayer, it’s being built on human effort—and that won’t hold. Final Word Church partnerships are not transactional arrangements. They are deeply spiritual alignments. They require:
Get those right, and you’ll see what I’ve seen—churches not just surviving, but being repositioned for gospel impact in ways they never could have imagined. Get them wrong, and you won’t just lose a deal. You’ll lose the opportunity for renewal. Is your church ready for a renewal conversation or open to partnering? Contact the Nashville Baptist Association and start a conversation.
0 Comments
 I Changed My Mind — Some Churches Need to Die
I’ve spent a good portion of my life trying to keep churches alive. I’ve walked into rooms where the lights were still on, but barely. Where the stories were strong, but the future was thin. Where people loved their church—but couldn’t quite figure out why it wasn’t reaching anyone anymore. And when God breathes life back into a congregation like that, there’s nothing like it. It’s sacred ground. It’s resurrection-level work. I’ve seen it happen. I believe in it. But somewhere along the way, I changed my mind. Some churches need to die. That’s not easy to say. It runs against instinct. It sounds harsh. It feels like giving up. But it’s not. It’s telling the truth. Death Is Not the Enemy We Think It Is We shouldn’t be surprised by this. Death is built into the gospel. Jesus didn’t call people to self-improvement—He called them to die. “Unless a grain of wheat falls into the earth and dies, it remains alone; but if it dies, it bears much fruit.” John 12:24 That’s not poetic language. That’s a principle. No death, no fruit. And that applies to churches just as much as it does to individuals. The problem is—we’ve gotten very good at keeping things alive that should have been surrendered a long time ago. Not Every Church Should Be Saved Let’s be clear: I’m not talking about churches that are struggling but willing. I’m not talking about congregations that are small but faithful. I’m not talking about churches that are declining but ready to repent, change, and move toward mission. Those churches? Fight for them. Invest in them. Walk with them. I’m talking about something else entirely. I’m talking about churches that:
At some point, the issue is no longer capability. It’s willingness. When willingness to die to self and follow Jesus is absent - organizational death is certain. How long depends on how much savingings they have to pull from or property to sell to prolong their existence. The Hard Reality We Avoid In my work, I’ve learned something most people don’t want to admit: Not every declining church has the same problem—and not every church has the same future. Too many leaders rush to solutions:
That’s treating symptoms. But diagnosis tells a different story. Real decline is usually deeper—spiritual, cultural, organizational, relational. And until you deal with the cause, no amount of activity will fix it. And here’s the part that takes courage: Some churches are not just struggling. They are no longer viable in their current form. They are out of alignment with their mission, their community, and sometimes even the gospel they claim to represent. And instead of dying with dignity and purpose, they linger. What Needs to Die Let’s bring this down to where it really lives. Before a church dies structurally, it should have already died spiritually—in the right ways. Here’s what I mean. 1. The church must die to self. Jesus’ mission has to take priority over personal agendas. Always. 2. The church must die to man-made traditions. Not everything we inherited is sacred. Some of it is just familiar. Some from a previous era - long passed. 3. The church must die to divisive people and patterns. Division, manipulation, and control are not “just part of church life.” They are toxins. The healthy church members need to rise up and not tolerate those behaviors anymore. 4. The church must die to the sin it tolerates. What a church refuses to confront sin, it eventually becomes the rot that destroys a church from the inside out. 5. The church must die to false gospels. Comfort, control, and consumerism are enemies of the cross. They promise more than they can deliver - and what they offer isn't life, but bondage that leads to death. If the church members refuse to die to those things… eventually the church will die. When Death Becomes Mercy This is where the conversation shifts. Because sometimes, the most faithful thing God can do is remove a lampstand. Not out of anger—but out of mercy. Mercy for:
We don’t like to think this way. But Scripture does. And if we’re honest, we’ve all seen churches that are no longer helping the mission—they’re hindering it. A Better Way Forward This isn’t a call to abandon troubled or declining churches. It’s a call to lead them honestly. There are more options than just “keep going” or “close the doors”:
But those decisions require courage. They require leaders who are willing to say: “If we do nothing, here’s what happens next.” And even harder: “If we are unwilling to change, we may not need a strategy—we may need an ending.” That’s not failure. That’s stewardship. Final Word I still believe in church renewal. I still fight for it. But I no longer believe every church should be preserved as it is at all costs. Because the goal was never survival. The goal was fruitfulness. And sometimes.... the only way to make room for new life… is to let something die.  When Giving Dips, Don’t Reach for the Plate—Research the Potential Reasons
You’ve seen this before. The numbers come in. Giving is down. Maybe not catastrophic—but enough to feel it. Enough to start asking questions. And almost immediately, the conversation goes the wrong direction.
Maybe. But maybe not. Because declining giving is not the problem—it’s the signal. And if you don’t diagnose it correctly, you’ll treat symptoms while the real issue keeps spreading underneath the surface. Don’t Fix Symptoms—Diagnose Causes One of the most helpful actions in understanding organizational work is this: You move from observing symptoms to researching causes before you ever prescribe solutions. Most churches skip that step. They see the symptom (giving is down) and jump straight to intervention (talk about giving more). But what if giving isn’t the issue? What if giving is revealing something else? Let’s Talk About What Could Be Going On After walking with enough churches through decline, conflict, and renewal, you start to see patterns. Giving doesn’t drop randomly. It drops for reasons. Here are some of the most common ones—and they’re not what most people expect. 1. When Trust Drops, Giving Follows This is the big one. People give where they trust. And they hesitate where they don’t. And here’s the part leaders often miss—trust is rarely lost because of one big moment. It erodes over time through observation and personal experiences. People are watching:
If something feels off—even if no one says it out loud—giving will start to reflect it. Not as rebellion. As a caution. 2. When People Don’t See Impact, They Stop Investing Nobody gives enthusiastically to maintain a system. They give to advance a mission. If all people see is:
And maintenance doesn’t inspire generosity. You don’t need hype—you need clarity. Where is life change happening? Where is the mission advancing? If people can’t see it, they won’t fund it. 3. When People Feel Unseen, They Disengage Giving is more relational than we want to admit. When people walk through:
They may still attend. They may still serve. But internally, they disconnect. And when connection fades, generosity usually follows. 4. When Giving Feels Like Pressure, It Eventually Breaks There’s a difference between calling people to obedience and pressuring them to perform. When giving is framed as:
But over time, it creates fatigue—and sometimes quiet resistance. People don’t sustain generosity under pressure. They sustain it when it’s rooted in worship and mission. 5. Sometimes People Aren’t Giving Because No One Is Leading Them To Give This is the quieter issue. In some churches, giving is assumed—but rarely taught, rarely connected to Scripture, rarely tied to vision. So people drift. Not out of rebellion. Out of lack of direction. You don’t have to manipulate—but you do have to lead. Cast vision, share stories and then walk them through the process. 6. Some People Withhold Giving to Send a Message This one makes leaders uncomfortable—but it’s real. When people feel like they have no voice, they look for leverage. And sometimes, that leverage is financial. It’s not healthy. But it is revealing. It usually points to:
7. Some People Are Quietly Struggling Financially Not every drop in giving is spiritual. Some people are carrying:
And no one knows. If your only response to declining giving is to push harder, you may unintentionally crush people who are already under pressure. A healthy church makes room for both generosity and grace. 8. Some People Have Just Drifted No conflict. No crisis. No protest. Just drift. And when spiritual engagement fades, giving usually fades with it.
9. The Generous Generation is Passing Away New generations do not give at the same level - not even close. Younger generations don’t have the margin - typically. This means when grandma and grandpa pass away you lose generous givers who were loyal, consistent and committed - financially. The younger generations give, and their level of sacrifice might be proportionate but it’s not equal in terms of real dollars. They’re paying for housing, school loans, kid care and the like. Conversations and education can adjust your expectations to this reality. 10. Attendance Patterns and Process As much as we dislike this - it’s true. People are attending church less frequently. That means those who only give when they attend are likely missing regular giving. Now-a-days it’s becoming more rare that offering plates are being passed. Giving boxes and online giving became the norm during COVID and they haven’t gone away - except in some churches. If you don’t have multiple ways for congregants to give - you’re missing out. Honestly, for those diehard offering plate passers an honest reading of Mark 12 shows us that in Jesus’ day offerings were made in boxes or receptacles not passed plates. You can debate, and plenty, if this is normative or prescriptive or descriptive. But here’s the point not to miss. You need multiple ways for people to give - plain and simple. A Word to the Frustrated There’s always a group that gets irritated when giving drops.
Look for the whole picture. If you assume the dip in generosity is primarily moral, you’ll miss the deeper reality—which is often relational, cultural, circumstantial or leadership-driven. You don’t correct a symptom by demanding it change. You understand why it exists. So What Do You Do?If giving is declining, don’t start with a campaign. Start with clarity. Here’s where I would begin. Rebuild Trust Be transparent. Communicate clearly. Address what’s been avoided. Trust isn’t rebuilt through statements—it’s rebuilt through consistent, observable behavior. Reconnect Giving to MissionTell real stories. Show real impact. People give to what they believe is making a difference. Strengthen Care Make sure people aren’t slipping through the cracks. You can’t expect deep investment from people who feel unseen. Teach Stewardship the Right Way Not as obligation—but as worship. Not as pressure—but as participation in what God is doing. Actually Lead on Giving Don’t assume people will connect the dots on their own. Tie generosity to Scripture. Tie it to vision. Make it clear and consistent. Create Healthy Ways for People to Be Heard If people feel voiceless, they’ll find other ways to communicate. Give them a better option. Pay Attention to Real Needs Not everyone who isn’t giving is unwilling. Some are just overwhelmed. Go After the Heart Because in the end, giving follows devotion. Always has. Always will. Final Thought If giving is down, resist the urge to fix it quickly. Quick fixes usually mean shallow understanding. And shallow understanding leads to the wrong solution. Slow down long enough to ask better questions. Listen. Observe. Diagnose. Because when you actually deal with what’s underneath-- Giving doesn’t just come back. It comes back healthier.  You’re sitting with a few friends—maybe over coffee, maybe between meetings.
The conversation turns, like it often does, to life. Work. Family. Ministry. The constant pressure of it all.
Then someone says it: “I’m just trying to find balance.” And at first, you nod. Of course. That’s the goal, right? But something in you hesitates. If you’re honest, something deeper pushes back: I don’t think that’s true. I don’t think balance is actually possible. And you’re right. The Problem with Balance Balance assumes life can be evenly distributed. It can’t. Life doesn’t arrive in neat categories. It comes in waves:
Trying to hold all of that in equilibrium doesn’t produce health. It produces fragmentation.
Balance isn’t just difficult—I believe it’s the wrong goal. Scripture Doesn’t Call You to Balance The Bible never calls you to a balanced life. It calls you to a faithful one. Jesus did not live a balanced life.
That is not balance. That is intentional obedience shaped by the moment and the mission. And Scripture is clear about how life actually works: “For everything there is a season, and a time for every matter under heaven: a time to be born, and a time to die; a time to plant, and a time to pluck up what is planted… a time to weep, and a time to laugh; a time to mourn, and a time to dance… a time to keep, and a time to cast away; a time to keep silence, and a time to speak.” (Ecclesiastes 3:1–7) Not everything at once. The right thing at the right time. The Real Issue: Misaligned Lives Most people aren’t struggling with balance. They’re struggling with alignment.
They’re trying to distribute their lives evenly instead of discerning what actually matters in the moment or season. Jesus doesn’t leave this unclear: “Seek first the kingdom of God…” (Matthew 6:33) That is not a call to balance. That is a call to rightly ordered priorities. Paul presses the same point: “Look carefully then how you walk… making the best use of the time.” (Ephesians 5:15–16) The issue is not equal time. It is wise stewardship of your life under God. Pace Is the Better Category Balance is static. Pace is dynamic. Pace recognizes:
Jesus lived with intentional pace:
He did not try to do everything at once. He did the right things at the right pace. Scripture Gives You Rhythms, Not Balance You see this pattern throughout the Bible: Urgency “I press on toward the goal…” (Philippians 3:14) Endurance “Run with endurance the race that is set before us…” (Hebrews 12:1) Rest “He restores my soul.” (Psalm 23:3) Waiting “Those who wait for the Lord shall renew their strength.” (Isaiah 40:31) The Christian life is not evenly paced. It is lived in rhythms of effort, rest, endurance, and trust. The problem isn’t working hard. The problem is living in one gear all the time. What Faithfulness Actually Requires You are not called to manage everything equally. You are called to: “Fulfill your ministry.” (2 Timothy 4:5) That requires clarity and courage. It means:
Even Jesus left real needs unmet in order to remain aligned with His mission: “Let us go on to the next towns… for that is why I came.” (Mark 1:38) That will never feel balanced. But it is faithful. A Better Way to Think About Your Life Stop aiming for balance. Think in three categories: Calling – What has God entrusted to you? “We are his workmanship… created in Christ Jesus for good works.” (Ephesians 2:10) Season – What is required right now? “For everything there is a season…” (Ecclesiastes 3:1) Pace – How should you move through it? “Teach us to number our days…” (Psalm 90:12) When those align, your life works—even when it feels full. When they don’t, no amount of balance will fix it. Bottom Line-Balance is a comforting idea. It’s just the wrong operating system. The goal is not equal distribution of your time. The goal is faithful execution of what matters most, at the right pace, in the right season, under God. Get that right—and you won’t need balance. A Final Word - Sabbath If pace is the issue, then Sabbath is not optional—it’s essential. Sabbath is God’s built-in interruption to your life. It cuts across every unhealthy pattern:
The answer isn’t to adjust harder. It’s to stop. “Remember the Sabbath day, to keep it holy…” (Exodus 20:8) Sabbath is not a reward for finishing your work. It’s a command that interrupts your work. Are you going full steam all the time? Sabbath. Are you moving slowly and frustrated by what’s undone? Sabbath. Are you trying to cram more in to make everything “balance”? Sabbath. Sabbath is part of pacing. It is a systematic, disruptive practice that resets:
It reminds you that you are not God, the work is not ultimate, and the world keeps turning without your constant effort. “The Sabbath was made for man…” (Mark 2:27) Part of faithful pacing is not just knowing when to push. It’s knowing when to stop. And trusting God enough to actually do it. |
Archives
May 2026
Categories
All
|
RSS Feed