 Have you ever heard this statement?
“A Pastor will only be able to reach people within ten years on either side of of his age.” I’ve heard that line for years. Recently, I’ve heard it used less as an observation and more as leverage—to shape pastor searches, justify staff transitions, and quietly dismiss candidates before their calling, leadership capacity, or fruit are seriously considered. So let’s deal with this honestly. What the statement actually says—and what it doesn’t The original statement is typically offered as a general pattern, not a rule. It speaks about average congregational age, not about a pastor’s capacity to relate, shepherd, disciple, or lead people outside a narrow age band. (find the link to the article originally cited below) But somewhere along the way, nuance disappeared. What gets repeated instead is something much stronger: “A pastor can only reach people within ten years of his age.” Let me SOUND THE ALARM!!! That claim is not supported by research, not biblically grounded, and frankly, not borne out by lived ministry experience. A personal word about age bias - I’ve seen this up close. Shortly after graduating seminary, I was part of a church plant where the founding pastor left just nine months into the work. There was significant internal conflict, and anyone who’s been around church planting knows that losing a pastor that early often spells doom. It did for us. I wanted the church to survive. I felt called to pastoral ministry and was growing to love those people deeply, so I put my name forward for consideration. One of the founding leaders—also a central figure in the conflict—declared loudly and publicly: “I’m not going to have a 30-year-old pastor!!” That was the end of the conversation. (Thank you Jesus for sparing me from that train wreck!) Fast forward. Today, I’m part of a three-year-old church plant where the majority of the congregation is the age of my adult children. We are loved, pursued, asked for counsel, invited into lives, and trusted—by young adults who are twenty to thirty years younger than we are (yes, that hurts to say out loud.) If the “ten-year rule” were true, none of that should be happening. Yet it is. What the research actually say Social science does acknowledge something called homophily—the tendency for people to form relationships with others who are similar to themselves, including age (McPherson, Smith-Lovin, & Cook, 2001). That explains default patterns, not fixed limits. In fact, a substantial body of research directly challenges the idea that age similarity determines relational capacity:
In short: people don’t merely tolerate multi-generational relationships. Many actively seek them. Everyone benefits form them. The real issue isn’t age—it’s design When a church becomes generationally narrow, the problem is rarely the pastor’s age. It’s usually the systems:
Blaming age is easier than doing the harder work of organizational and spiritual formation. And now, the biblical issue. Let’s be clear: this age-based dismissal is not biblical. Paul told Timothy plainly: “Don’t let anyone look down on you because you are young…” (1 Timothy 4:12) Scripture also consistently honors “seasoned” saints—men and women whose faith, wisdom, and endurance are gifts to the body. Older men and women are explicitly instructed to teach, encourage, disciple, and train younger believers (Titus 2). A multi-generational church is not a concession to culture—it is faithfulness to Scripture. So when we discount someone because of age—young or old—we are neither biblical nor Christlike. Let me be abundantly frank: When churches talk about putting pastors or staff “out to pasture” because of age, when they are dismissive to and of younger pastors, when consultants or denominational employees spout the +/- Ten year age statement as fact...... stop it. Please. Just stop it. Now, I need to be clear - if a Pastor (young or old) isn’t able to lead effectively, if he is unresponsive to the congregation, unwilling to change, exhibiting a poor work ethic, angry, bitter, hostile, derelict (you ge the idea) - a change should be made. That’s based on leadership competency, character and capacity not age. I’ve met energetic and sharp 70 year olds and low energy, unmotivated and unable to lead 30 year olds. Again, age alone is not a limiting factor. I've Pastored people 40 years more senior and almost as many my junior. We had a great Pastor - Congregant relationship. In fact, a young family joined our church precisely because I was older (back then I was in my mid-to-late 40s.) Age is a number, not always a mark of effectiveness or ineffectiveness or relevance. A wildly secular example (and no endorsement implied)Permit me one unrelated, but kinda related example. Bernie Sanders—an extremely senior U.S. Senator—is deeply popular with very young voters. Why? Not because he’s their age, but because his message resonates. I am not endorsing Sanders. I disagree with him fundamentally, but the point is obvious: message, credibility, and authenticity matter more than age. A better question for pastor search teams Instead of asking: “Is this candidate close enough to our target demographic?” Ask: “Does this leader have the character, calling, competencies, and capacity to lead across generations?” That’s a biblical question. That’s a leadership question. And that’s where evaluation belongs. Final words
They are built by biblical faithfulness, intentional leadership, and multi-generational relationships. Would your church benefit from growing younger? Defiately so. Here’s a good article exploring some steps a congregation with that desire may want to consider: (read the Vanderbloemen article) It’s also the article that is often wrongly cited to move out older staff and disqualify younger candidates. Academic References
0 Comments
 Every pastor who steps into a declining church carries hope—often shared hope. The church says they want to reach their community. They long to see new life. They pray for growth, renewal, and impact.
So when a pastor begins leading toward that future—and meets resistance—it can feel confusing, discouraging, and deeply personal. But sometimes what’s happening isn’t failure. It may be calling. Not every pastoral call is a “promised land” assignment. Some are unmistakably wilderness calls. And wilderness work matters just as much in the economy of God. Understanding the Season You’ve Been Given In Scripture, God often did His most formative work in desert places. The wilderness was not a detour—it was the assignment. Israel didn’t wander because Moses failed. They wandered because God was shaping a people who were not yet ready to live freely. Old idols had to die. New trust had to be formed. Dependence had to be learned daily. Some pastors are called to lead churches into seasons of fruitfulness and visible growth. Others are called to guide churches through desert days—seasons marked by resistance, fear, and slow, hidden work. That calling is not lesser. It is essential. When Vision Meets Resistance Many pastors discover that the resistance they face does not come from “the church” as a whole, but from a small number of influential voices. These individuals often see themselves as protectors—of tradition, finances, facilities, or harmony. They may genuinely believe they are acting in the church’s best interest. And yet, their fear, control, or need for stability can quietly restrict obedience and mission. For a pastor, this can feel like walking in circles—progress proposed, then delayed; enthusiasm expressed, then quietly undercut. In a wilderness season, the pastor’s role is not to force arrival—but to shepherd faithfully through uncertainty. The Work of a Wilderness Pastor Wilderness pastors are called to a particular kind of faithfulness: Formation Over FruitionThe work is often unseen. Growth is internal before it is numerical. Hearts, assumptions, and loyalties are slowly exposed and reshaped. Patience Over Speed Forward movement happens in inches, not miles. God teaches His people to walk daily, not rush ahead. Dependence Over Control The wilderness strips away illusions of quick fixes and human strength. Pastors learn again—and teach their churches—to trust God for daily bread. Clarity Over Comfort in desert seasons, truth must be spoken carefully but clearly. The pastor names reality, teaches Scripture, and calls the church to obedience—without demanding immediate results. Guarding Your Heart in the Desert Wilderness callings are hard on pastors. Discouragement comes easily. Weariness settles in quietly. Comparison becomes tempting. This is where calling matters. Some shepherds are called to plant and harvest. Some are called to plow rocky ground. Some are called to weaken old patterns so that future leaders can build more freely. If your assignment is wilderness work, it does not mean you will see the promised land with your own eyes. Moses didn’t—and his faithfulness was not diminished because of it. Faithfulness Is the Measure A wilderness calling does not ask, “Did you grow the church?” It asks, “Did you shepherd the people God entrusted to you?” “Did you teach truth?” “Did you model trust?” “Did you remain obedient when progress was slow?” The Kingdom of God is advanced not only through visible victories, but through long obedience in hard places. And many churches that later flourish do so because a faithful pastor once walked with them through the desert. If that is your calling, take heart. God does not waste wilderness seasons. And He does not forget the shepherds who walk them faithfully.  A Simple Practice That Builds a Fellowshipping Culture
Most churches say they want deeper connection, stronger relationships, and a genuine sense of care among their people. Fewer churches intentionally design for it. Fellowship doesn’t happen by accident. It happens when leaders decide it matters enough to create space for it. One of the simplest, most effective ways to do that is a regular coffee hour after the morning service—or between morning services. It’s not flashy. It’s not complicated. And yes, some people will scoff at it. But over time, it quietly does its work. Fellowship Is Not Optional — It’s Biblical The New Testament assumes believers will know one another, care for one another, and share life together. The early church gathered around teaching and table fellowship. Conversation, presence, and relational connection weren’t add-ons; they were part of discipleship. Your congregation already wants this. They want to talk. They want to check in. They want to be known and to know others. When churches don’t provide a natural space for that to happen, people either rush out to the parking lot—or try to create connection in fragmented, inconsistent ways. A simple coffee hour says, We expect fellowship to happen here. Why Coffee Hour Works A regular coffee hour is far less involved and far less time-consuming than standing fellowship meals, yet it delivers real relational return.
Over time, repeated small interactions build familiarity. Familiarity builds trust. Trust opens the door to care, compassion, and spiritual support. People don’t need an occasional three-hour meal to connect. They need consistent (weekly), unhurried space to connect and converse. The Logistics Are Simple (Not Effortless) This works best in one of two ways:
Either way, clarity matters. People need to know this is not optional filler time—it’s part of the Sunday experience. Here are the key ingredients:
Vision Casting Is What Makes or Breaks It Coffee alone doesn’t create fellowship. Pastoral vision does. Leaders must consistently:
This isn’t a one-time announcement. It’s ongoing culture shaping. People need permission—sometimes repeated permission—to slow down, engage, and step outside familiar relational circles. When leaders model this behavior, the congregation follows. Equip People for Meaningful Connection Left on its own, a coffee hour can drift into predictable conversations among the same groups of people. To prevent that, churches should actively equip their people. That means equipping your congregation in the following:
You don’t need a training seminar. A few well-placed reminders from the pulpit and modeled behavior from leaders go a long way. Culture Is Formed Over Time This sounds simple—and it is. But don’t underestimate its cumulative impact. A regular coffee hour:
Over time, this practice shapes and reinforces a culture where people expect to welcome and be welcomed, to know and be known, to care and be cared for. It becomes part of the church’s DNA. Simple doesn’t mean shallow. When practiced consistently and led with vision, a coffee hour can quietly become one of the most formative things a church does. And that’s a small thing that makes a big difference.  Why an Authentic Greeting Time Still Matters
Every so often, the “stand and greet” moment in worship gets put on trial again.
Let me be clear: the problem is rarely greeting itself. The problem is shallow, poorly led, socially unaware greeting and those who elevate personal discomfort or preference above biblical example and sociological research.. Scripture Is Unambiguous: Welcome Is Core to Christian Community The New Testament does not prescribe a specific worship element called “greeting time.” But it repeatedly commands something far more fundamental: visible, embodied welcome.
Even the repeated apostolic instruction to “greet one another” (Romans 16; 1 Corinthians 16:20; 2 Corinthians 13:12) reminds us that acknowledging one another mattered. The cultural expression changes. The theological value does not. A church that never creates space to notice one another may be efficient—but it is not deeply biblical. Sociology Confirms What Scripture Assumes Modern research simply confirms what Scripture has assumed all along: humans are wired for belonging. Psychologists Roy Baumeister and Mark Leary demonstrated that the need to belong is a fundamental human motivation. People seek stable, positive relational connections, and when they don’t find them, they disengage. Sociological studies of congregations consistently show:
At the same time, research (including work summarized by Lifeway Research) shows many visitors prefer not to be publicly singled out or pressured. That insight does not argue against welcome. It argues against poorly designed welcome. People want warmth without exposure. Connection without coercion. The Real Question Is Not Whether to Greet, but How A healthy greeting time is not:
An authentic greeting time is:
A simple biblical frame (10 seconds) “Because Christ has welcomed us, we want to welcome one another. Take a moment to greet the people around you. A simple ‘good morning’ is enough.” That one sentence does a lot of work: it grounds the moment in Romans 15:7, lowers social pressure, honors different personalities, and sets expectations clearly. Sixty to ninety seconds is enough. Long enough to communicate value. Short enough to avoid awkward wandering. Designing a Greeting Time for Introverts and Extroverts Introversion and extroversion are real. Both bring gifts to leadership. But neither gets to define the church’s theology of welcome. The solution is tiered participation. Teach the congregation that greeting has levels:
Now everyone can participate honestly without pretending to be someone they’re not. This isn’t lowering the bar—it’s pastoral wisdom. Social Intelligence Matters More Than Enthusiasm If greetings are going to work, people must be taught to read the room. Green light (engage a bit more):
Red light (exit kindly):
Helpful Phrases That Build Trust Good first words:
A Necessary Warning About Anti-Greeting Advocates Here’s the hard truth leaders need to hear: When someone’s opposition to greeting time is driven primarily by personal discomfort, it is not neutral wisdom—it is bias. Warning signs include:
Introverts offer critical leadership insight. But introversion does not get to veto hospitality. Scripture, sociology, and church leadership research all point in the same direction: belonging precedes commitment. A church that removes relational on-ramps in the name of efficiency may be smooth—but it will not be warm. And it will quietly lose people who never felt seen. Final Word: An authentic greeting time is not about nostalgia or trends. It is about forming a culture that reflects the gospel we proclaim. Done poorly, it should be corrected. Done thoughtfully, it disciples a congregation in hospitality every single week. The question is not whether greeting belongs in worship. The real question is whether we will design it biblically, lead it wisely, and practice it with social intelligence. That’s not fluff. That’s shepherding.  Most long-time church folks don’t like to admit it, but here’s the truth: our hearts often break over the wrong things.
We mourn the loss of a ministry program we liked. We grieve when a familiar rhythm changes. We get anxious when the sanctuary looks emptier than it did ten years ago. We feel threatened when our “safe” church world shifts. But those aren’t the griefs that move heaven. They’re just the griefs that move us. And too often, our emotional life around church is tied to nostalgia, comfort, predictability, and personal preference—not the spiritual condition of the people living right outside our doors. We love the building, the history, the memories, the stability. But Jesus didn’t give His life to preserve our comfort; He gave His life to rescue the lost. What Jesus Actually Grieved Over When Jesus looked at the crowds, He didn’t see:
He saw lostness. “He had compassion for them, because they were harassed and helpless, like sheep without a shepherd.” — Matthew 9:36 That compassion wasn’t mild. It was gut-deep grief. Holy grief. And out of that grief, Jesus didn’t tell His disciples to guard religious traditions. He told them to plead with God for more workers—more people willing to step into the harvest. So ask yourself: What am I actually grieving over? Our Common Griefs Are Too Small Let’s be honest. Many Christians are grieving over:
These concerns are real, but they aren’t eternal. Meanwhile, all around us are people wrestling with:
They are spiritually hungry—and they’re everywhere. This is the grief that should move us. This is the grief the gospel produces. What Gospel Grief Really Is Gospel Grief is not nostalgia. It’s not preference panic. It’s not irritation over change. Gospel Grief is the Spirit-shaped ache that comes from seeing people like Jesus sees them. It’s the inward movement that says:
Gospel Grief lays down preferences and prays: “Use me, Lord. It’s not about what I like—it’s about who You love.” Practicing Gospel Grief: If Gospel Grief is going to take root in your heart and your church, you must intentionally cultivate it. Here’s where to start: 1. Pay Attention on the Way to Worship - Look at the neighborhoods, people, traffic, storefronts, and lives you pass. Pray: “Lord, give me Your eyes today.” 2. Spend Money in Your Church’s Neighborhood - Buy gas, coffee, lunch, groceries close to your church. Learn the heartbeat of the community. See the faces. Hear the conversations. You can’t love people you avoid. 3. Lay Down Complaints Immediately - When the preference-based frustration rises-- “I miss the old way…” “Why don’t we still…” “It’s not the same…”
Then ask: “Who near us is spiritually adrift, and how do we reach them?” 4. Pray for the Spirit to Redirect Your Heart, not once—but continually. “Spirit, break my heart for what breaks Yours. Correct my loves. Shape my grief toward Your mission.” The Future Depends on Gospel Grief Churches stuck in nostalgia drift toward irrelevance. Churches fueled by Gospel Grief move toward mission. One path leads to slow death. The other leads to life. If we want to be faithful in this moment, we don’t need more guardians of church comfort. We need more harvesters moved by the same compassion that moved the heart of Christ. So let’s stop grieving the wrong things. Let’s start grieving the eternal things. And let that grief push us back into the mission of Jesus—right here, right now, among the people who need Him most.  (Translation by David Quiora - Replant Team, North American Mission Board)
Querido Don controlador , El declive de la iglesia crea un vacío Cuanto más tiempo ha estado en declive una iglesia, es menos probable que quede líderes fuertes y visionarios en los bancos. Lo intentaron. Hablaron. Ofrecieron ideas y energía. Pero fueron ignorados, resistidos o atacados. Finalmente, se fueron. A menudo se trata de líderes capaces en su vida profesional: personas que lideran equipos, resuelven problemas y toman decisiones todos los días. Luchan sus batallas en el trabajo. No quieren pelear con los mismos en la iglesia. Su expectativa es simple: los seguidores de Cristo deben unirse en torno a la misión, no especializarse en los menores. Así que se escabullen silenciosamente. Y cuando lo hacen, sucede algo crítico: el equilibrio de influencia cambia. El ascenso de los controladores Cuando los líderes sanos se van, los controladores se apresuran a llenar el vacío. No son visionarios; son guardianes de lo familiar. Bajo el noble estandarte de "proteger y preservar la iglesia", toman el control de los comités, los presupuestos y las decisiones, y se aferran a ese control por su vida. Lo llaman fidelidad. Pero en realidad es miedo. En verdad, lo que están preservando no es el evangelio, es comodidad y control. La mayoría de los miembros de una iglesia en declive no se resisten intencionalmente a la misión. Simplemente quieren un lugar seguro y predecible para adorar, estudiar su Biblia y disfrutar del compañerismo. Anhelan estabilidad. Pero con el tiempo, la comodidad se convierte en la misión. La gente nueva trae nuevas ideas. Las nuevas ideas traen cambios. Y el cambio se siente como una pérdida. Así que la iglesia ora por el crecimiento mientras rechaza silenciosamente las mismas cosas que podrían traerlo. El controlador espiritualizado El controlador más peligroso no es el ruidoso ni el obvio. Es el espiritual, la persona que oculta el control en un lenguaje piadoso. Dicen todas las cosas correctas:
Pero detrás de escena, manipulan, presionan y dirigen los resultados a su manera. Dominan las discusiones, influyen en los votos, zumban y agotan a los que quieren un diálogo significativo, despliegan el veto de bolsillo mientras socavan silenciosamente cualquier cosa que amenace su posición o traiga progreso. En una consulta reciente, conocí a un hombre así. Dijo todas las cosas correctas y sonó profundamente espiritual. Sin embargo, su comportamiento contó una historia diferente. Otro consultor que había trabajado con la misma iglesia me dijo claramente: "Esa iglesia nunca crecerá hasta que él quite las manos de todo o el Señor lo mueva". Esa no es una situación rara. Es una tragedia recurrente. Los controladores de complicidad de la Congregación solo prosperan porque la gente se lo permite. La mayoría de los miembros de la iglesia no son controladores, simplemente están cansados. Han visto conflictos antes y no quieren otra ronda. Así que permanecen en silencio. Se llevan bien. Pero el silencio es complicidad. Al no hacer nada, lo entregan todo. La congregación puede orar sinceramente por la renovación, pero la oración sin coraje y confrontación simplemente bautiza el status quo. El declive continúa, los líderes permanecen en silencio y el controlador sigue dirigiendo el barco, directamente hacia las rocas. Cuando solo Dios puede quitarlos Aveces, solo Dios puede quitar un controlador. Y lo hace, por convicción, por circunstancias o por moverlos a otra parte. Pero hasta que eso suceda, la iglesia permanece estancada.
Porque la misión de Jesús vale más que el sentido de control de cualquiera. Una última palabra para el " Don Controlador " Si ese eres tú, el que insiste en que solo quieres la voluntad de Dios mientras te aseguras de que todo salga como quieres, si crees que sabes más, si dices una cosa pero en realidad no lo dices en serio, es hora de arrepentirte, soltar tu control o vete de la iglesia. La iglesia de Dios no es tuya para administrarla. Es de El para liderar. Y a cada miembro cansado y líder tímido: dejen de permitir el control. Di la verdad. Avanza. La iglesia no necesita más controladores. Necesita más coraje. En pocas palabras: cuando los controladores gobiernan la iglesia, la misión muere. Cuando Cristo gobierna, la iglesia vive de nuevo. Cuando los controladores gobiernan la iglesia  Church Decline Creates a Vacuum
The longer a church has been in decline, the less likely it is to have strong, visionary leaders left in the pews. They tried. They spoke up. They offered ideas and energy. But they were ignored, resisted, or attacked. Eventually, they left. These are often capable leaders in their professional lives — people who lead teams, solve problems, and make decisions every day. They fight their battles at work. They don’t want to fight the same ones in church. Their expectation is simple: Christ-followers should unite around mission, not major on the minors. So they quietly slip away. And when they do, something critical happens — the balance of influence shifts. The Rise of the Controllers When healthy leaders exit, controllers rush in to fill the void. They’re not visionaries; they’re guardians of the familiar. Under the noble-sounding banner of “protecting and preserving the church,” they seize control of committees, budgets, and decisions — and they hold on to that control for dear life. They call it faithfulness. But it’s really fear. In truth, what they’re preserving isn’t the gospel — it’s comfort and control. Most members in a long-declining church aren’t intentionally resistant to mission. They simply want a safe and predictable place to worship, study their Bible, and enjoy fellowship. They long for stability. But over time, comfort becomes the mission. New people bring new ideas. New ideas bring change. And change feels like loss. So the church prays for growth while quietly rejecting the very things that could bring it. The Spiritualized Controller The most dangerous controller isn’t the loud or obvious one. It’s the spiritual one — the person who cloaks control in pious language. They say all the right things:
But behind the scenes, they manipulate, lobby, and steer outcomes their way. They dominate discussions, influence votes, they drone on and one exhausting those who want meaningful dialouge, they deploy the pocket veto all the while quietly undermining anything that threatens their position or brings progress. In a recent consultation, I met such a man. He said all the right things and sounded deeply spiritual. Yet his behavior told a different story. Another consultant who’d worked with the same church told me plainly: “That church will never grow until he either takes his hands off everything or the Lord moves him on.” That’s not a rare situation. It’s a recurring tragedy. The Congregation’s Complicity Controllers only thrive because people let them. Most church members aren’t controllers — they’re simply tired. They’ve seen conflict before and don’t want another round. So they stay silent. They go along to get along. But silence is complicity. By doing nothing, they hand over everything. The congregation may sincerely pray for renewal, but prayer without courage and confrontation simply baptizes the status quo. Decline continues, leaders stay silent, and the controller keeps steering the ship — right into the rocks. When Only God Can Remove Them Sometimes, only God can remove a controller. And He does — through conviction, through circumstance, or by moving them elsewhere. But until that happens, the church remains stuck.
It doesn’t have to be that way. God can and does revive His church — but revival always begins with repentance. Controllers must release their grip. Members must find their voice. And leaders must stand up and lead, even when it costs them. Because the mission of Jesus is worth more than anyone’s sense of control. A Final Word to “Mr. Controlly McControlerton” If that’s you — the one who insists you only want God’s will while ensuring everything still goes your way — if you believe you know better, if you say one thing but don't really mean it, it’s time to repent, release your grip or leave the church. God’s church isn’t yours to manage. It’s His to lead. And to every weary member and timid leader: stop enabling control. Speak truth. Lead forward. The church doesn’t need more controllers. It needs more courage. Bottom line: When controllers rule the church, the mission dies. When Christ rules, the church lives again.  When a pastor leaves, most churches feel the same pressure: “We’ve got to find someone—fast.” A search committee forms, a job listing is posted, and résumés, lots of them, begin to roll in. Committee members get overwhelmed, Candidates grow impatient. After some time, the church “calls” someone who seems promising, or who hasn’t already accepted another position, or at worst-both the would be pastor and the desperate congregation choose each other in a relationship that may be destined for failure from the jump. Too often, the honeymoon between Pastor and People begins to fade by year three. Conflict, burnout, or disillusionment set in. Another resignation follows. Possibly another Pastor leaves the ministry. For the Church comes a year of interim ministry, another year of searching, and before you know it—six years have passed, and the church is right back where it started, searching. And, likely this time with fewer and more frustrated people. This isn’t a rare occurrence. Research from the Jim Henry Leadership Institute (New Orleans Baptist Theological Seminary) places the average tenure of Southern Baptist pastors at about 3.5 to 4 years. In other words, many churches spend almost as much time recovering from a pastoral mismatch as they do being led by a pastor. It’s time to rethink our process. The Problem: Job Listings and Résumés Can’t Reveal Calling or Fit Posting a job listing and collecting résumés may work fine for hiring outside the church. But calling a pastor is not just an employment decision—it’s a spiritual discernment process. A résumé can tell you where someone has served, but not how they lead under pressure, how patient they will be with change resistant seniors, how fast they want to move, how they handle disagreement, or how they fit within a congregation’s culture and story. Likewise, a church’s website and bylaws might tell a candidate what the church does—but not what the people are really like, or what kind of health the body truly has. How and why their previous Pastor and the two or three before him left their post. A job posting won’t reveal how healthy or vibrant the congregation actually is or how many “controllers” or “gatekeepers” have navigated their way into positions of influence. A quick hire based on surface compatibility may bring short-term relief but long-term pain. Churches who rush the process, who are less transparent on the front end up with pastors who were never prepared for the church’s condition, and pastors find themselves in cultures that resist their leadership from day one. When the call process is reduced to an exchange of résumés, we risk bypassing the very thing the New Testament calls us to: spiritual discernment. The Necessity of Understanding a Church’s True Condition Before searching for a pastor, a church must take an honest look in the mirror:
If a church does not first understand its own condition, it can’t know what kind of pastoral leadership it needs. A church in conflict might require a patient healer. A plateaued church may need a visionary disciple-maker. A young congregation might need a stabilizing teacher. When a church seeks guidance and conducts a spiritual health assessment before launching a search, it begins to clarify its identity and readiness. That clarity helps ensure it calls not just a pastor, but the right pastor for this moment. The Danger of “Just Finding a Pastor” The pressure to “just find someone” is real. Members grow weary of transition. Attendance drifts. Giving declines. Leaders feel anxious. But haste in calling a pastor often leads to regret. Every rushed search carries hidden costs:
When churches allow urgency or fatigue to replace discernment, they trade temporary relief for long-term instability. “There’s a reason the Spirit led the church at Antioch to pray, fast, and wait before setting apart Barnabas and Saul” (Acts 13:2–3). The call of a pastor is too sacred to be rushed, too important to not be really clear on the health of the congregation and the kind of Pastor it needs (but may not want.) The Cost of the Cycle: Lost Time and Lost Momentum Let’s do the math: If the average pastor serves 3–4 years, and each departure triggers:
When this happens, every 3-year tenure produces roughly a 6-year down cycle before stable ministry returns. That’s six years where energy, trust, and momentum are drained instead of built. Multiply that over a generation, and it’s easy to see why many churches plateau or decline despite sincere effort. A Healthier Way Forward The solution isn’t complicated, but it does require courage, patience and humility. A healthy call process includes:
When churches and pastors discern together rather than hire hastily, they create the conditions for lasting ministry fruit. A Word to Churches and Candidates
Thinking Beyond the Traditional Search A Better Way to Find a Pastor If the standard “post-and-pray” method isn’t working, it’s time to rethink where and how we look for pastoral leaders. Rather than relying solely on job postings and résumé submissions, churches can take a more relational and Spirit-led approach to discovering their next pastor. 1. Ask Your Denominational Leaders Associational Mission Strategists, State Convention Staff, and trusted denominational partners often know pastors, planters, or ministry leaders who are ready for a new assignment or who fit the kind of leader your church needs. These leaders see patterns across many congregations and can often recommend candidates who would never apply online but who might be a perfect fit. 2. Network with Healthy Churches Ask pastors of strong, healthy congregations if they have team members or associates who may be ready to step into a lead role. Churches that are developing leaders are often glad to see those leaders deployed into struggling or plateaued congregations where they can make an impact. 3. Seek Out Churches with Pastoral Residencies Many churches invest in training and preparing future pastors through residency programs. Reaching out to those congregations allows your search team to connect with candidates who have already been mentored, evaluated, and tested in real ministry environments. 4. Look Within Your Own Congregation Sometimes God is already raising up your next pastor from within your own fellowship. A faithful lay leader, staff member, or ministry volunteer may demonstrate spiritual maturity, character, and gifting that indicate a call to pastoral leadership. Don’t overlook those God has been preparing right under your roof. 5. Above All, Pray and Seek God’s Direction No process, search tool, or network replaces prayer. The call of a pastor is a sacred connection that only God can orchestrate. Ask Him to align hearts, reveal motives, and connect the right candidate and congregation at the right time. When churches pursue relationship over résumés, discernment over data, and prayer over pressure, they position themselves to find not just a pastor—but God’s pastor for their next chapter. The health of a church and the longevity of its pastor are not determined by who gets hired first, but by how deeply both parties listen to the Spirit before committing. A prayerful, honest process may take longer—but it bears fruit that lasts. “We proclaim Him, warning and teaching everyone with all wisdom, so that we may present everyone mature in Christ. I labor for this, striving with His strength that works powerfully in me.” — Colossians 1:28–29  I talk with a lot of declining churches. They’ve seen better days — the sanctuary once full, the baptistry once stirred, the sound of kids running the halls replaced by the echo of silence. And now, after years of slow decline, the conversation turns toward hope:
“We need a new pastor.” But what they usually mean is:
The assumption is that decline is primarily a leadership style problem — that if they can just find the right kind of pastor, the church will start growing again. But here’s the truth: You don’t just need a new pastor. You need a Spirit-guided, biblically grounded, missionally minded shepherd who will lead you to follow Jesus, engage your community with the gospel, and make disciples — not just attenders. And that means something hard but hopeful: You need a pastor who will lead you to believe what you haven’t believed, surrender what you’ve clung to, and follow Christ more fully than you ever have before. The Pastor You Need Will Make You Uncomfortable. Let’s be honest — most churches in decline didn’t get there overnight, and they didn’t get there by accident. Decline is almost always spiritual before it’s numerical. It’s the slow drift from mission to maintenance, from gospel urgency to personal comfort. So the pastor you truly need will not exist to make you comfortable. He won’t just affirm what you already love. He’ll call you to repentance, challenge your assumptions, and confront your idols — because Jesus doesn’t build His church through comfort, but through the cross. A faithful pastor will remind you that following Jesus means dying to self, taking up your cross, and walking in obedience, even when it’s hard. That means there will be Sundays when you don’t “like” church. You might not like what you hear. You might feel convicted. You might be asked to give more, serve more, forgive more, and love more deeply than you ever have before. But those are the very marks of revival. Because God doesn’t send revival to the comfortable — He sends it to the surrendered. You Need a Shepherd Who Will Lead You to Follow Jesus Again. The church you long to become will not be reborn through clever programs or the perfect hire. It will be reborn through repentance and renewal — through the power of the Word of God, the work of the Spirit, and a people willing to be led. You need a pastor who will:
That kind of pastor will not simply be a chaplain to your preferences. He will be a shepherd to your souls — leading you into obedience, prayer, evangelism, and gospel-driven unity. The Real Question: Are You Willing to Be Led? Every church says they want a “good leader,” but few are willing to be led. It’s one thing to hire a pastor; it’s another to follow one. If you want God to bring life again, you must be willing to follow where He leads — even when it means:
The kind of pastor who can lead you there won’t always make you comfortable. But he will confront you to be more Christlike. And that’s what your church needs most. Hope for the Church That’s Willing Here’s the good news: Jesus loves His church — even the declining ones. He is still the Head, still the Builder, still the One who brings life from death. He raises up shepherds for His sheep, not to preserve what was, but to lead toward what can be — a renewed people, walking in obedience, proclaiming His gospel, and making disciples to the ends of the earth.
Because the church that dies to itself is the church Christ will raise again.  Paul’s words here hit home for anyone who carries the weight of shepherding multiple churches. This isn't a theoretical concern—it's a gritty, soul-deep, all-consuming burden. Not because we’re saviors, but because we care. Deeply. And when you're an Associational Leader, you're not just a bystander; you're on the front lines.
The Role Few See But Many Rely On Let’s be clear: no one signs up to be an Associational Mission Strategist or Director of Missions because it’s easy. We do it because we're called to contend for healthy churches. That means:
It’s messy, misunderstood, underappreciated work. And it’s holy ground. We Are Not the Savior—Jesus Is The good news? You don’t have to die for the church. Jesus already did. Your role isn’t to be crucified—your role is to be faithful. Faithful to show up. Faithful to speak truth in love (Ephesians 4:15). Faithful to challenge complacency (Titus 2:15). Faithful to encourage the faint-hearted (1 Thessalonians 5:14). Faithful to rebuke when necessary (2 Timothy 4:2). Faithful to call them back to the mission (Matthew 28:19-20). You’re Not Alone in the Pressure If Paul felt the weight of the churches daily, you can bet we’re going to feel it too. It’s part of the calling. But here’s the key: you can’t carry this pressure alone. “My grace is sufficient for you, for my power is made perfect in weakness.” — 2 Corinthians 12:9 This pressure we carry is a privilege, but it’s also a reminder: we need His power. We need His Spirit. We need His Word. And we need each other. Let’s not fool ourselves into thinking grit alone will sustain us. We need grace. Daily. Hourly. Moment by moment. Stay the Course—God Sees To every Associational Leader driving across counties, walking into conflict-heavy rooms, challenging churches stuck in the past, cheering for bivocational pastors, and giving another yes when your tank is low: God sees you. “God is not unjust; He will not forget your work and the love you have shown Him as you have helped His people.” — Hebrews 6:10 He sees your labor. He hears your prayers. He honors your faithfulness. So, What Now?
You’re not alone. You’re not crazy. You’re not wasting your time. Keep showing up. Keep telling the truth. Keep pointing churches to Jesus and His mission. And remember: the church doesn’t rest on your shoulders. It rests on His. |
RSS Feed