BOBBICKFORD.COM
  • Home
  • Blog
  • About
  • Resources
  • Contact

Walk Toward the Conflict

8/11/2026

0 Comments

 
Picture
A word to pastors who would rather keep the peace than confront what is harming the church

Most pastors do not enter ministry because they enjoy conflict.

They love people. They want to preach the Word, care for families, make disciples, reach the community, and help the church flourish. When tension surfaces, their first instinct is often to calm it, absorb it, postpone the hard conversation, or hope the problem resolves itself.

That instinct is understandable. But it can also be dangerous.

There are moments when a pastor must walk toward conflict rather than run away from it. Not every disagreement deserves confrontation. Not every problem requires a public response. But when false teaching, persistent sin, destructive behavior, or congregational division threatens the health of the church and the advance of the mission, avoidance is not peacemaking. It is a failure to protect the flock.

Pastor, you do not have to become combative. You do have to become courageous.

Conflict Aversion Is Common
Conflict aversion is a habitual reluctance to enter, remain in, or directly address disagreement because of the discomfort, anxiety, rejection, anger, or relational loss a person expects conflict to produce.

It often looks respectable.
  • We delay the meeting.
  • We soften the issue until no one understands its seriousness.
  • We change the subject, communicate indirectly, or make one gentle pass and then retreat when the person pushes back.

How many people are conflict averse?
There is no single, clinically settled percentage because researchers measure different things: personality, conflict style, workplace behavior, or avoidance of a particular conversation. But the tendency is widespread. A
2026 national survey of 1,000 American adults found that 85 percent had avoided at least one conversation during the previous 30 days because it might lead to conflict. Forty-two percent said their first instinct during disagreement was to change the subject or end the conversation.


That does not mean 85 percent of Americans possess a permanently conflict-averse personality. It does mean avoidance is a normal human impulse.

Pastors are not exempt from it. In fact, ministry can intensify it. A difficult conversation may threaten a friendship, awaken an influential family, provoke anonymous criticism, cost the church members, divide a meeting, or put a pastor’s livelihood at risk.

So avoidance begins to feel prudent. We call it patience. We call it waiting on the Lord. We say we are preserving unity.
  • Sometimes that is exactly what patience requires.
  • Sometimes it is simply fear using spiritual language.

Avoided Conflict Does Not Disappear
Unaddressed conflict rarely remains contained. It travels through a congregation.

​Organizationally, a church is a system of relationships, leadership patterns, communication pathways, ministry practices, and formal and informal authority. A disruptive person does not affect only the pastor. False teaching does not remain inside one classroom. Persistent gossip does not stay in one conversation. An influential member’s contempt for leadership does not stop at the committee-room door.

What leaders permit in one part of the system eventually teaches the whole system what is acceptable.

When a pastor repeatedly avoids necessary conflict:
  • Confusion replaces clarity because no one knows what the church actually believes or expects.
  • Informal power grows because the boldest person learns that resistance produces control.
  • Healthy members become discouraged because leaders will not protect them.
  • Staff members and volunteers spend their energy managing dysfunction rather than serving the mission.
  • Resentment moves underground and reappears as gossip, triangulation, passive resistance, and distrust.
  • The congregation’s public witness suffers.
  • The mission stalls because everyone’s attention turns inward.

The visible conflict may be only a symptom. Beneath it may be unresolved sin, loss of trust, an entrenched power structure, false doctrine, or years of leadership retreat.

Sound pastoral diagnosis asks what is actually happening, who is being harmed, what biblical standard applies, and what response fits the problem. But diagnosis is not an excuse for endless delay. Once the matter is clear, faithful leadership acts.

Peace is not merely the absence of tension. Biblical peace is the fruit of truth, righteousness, repentance, reconciliation, and rightly ordered relationships.

Silence may make a meeting quieter while making the church sicker.

Paul Did Not Send Timothy to Ephesus to Avoid Trouble

​Timothy’s assignment was difficult from the beginning. Paul urged him to remain in Ephesus so he could “instruct certain people not to teach false doctrine” (1 Timothy 1:3, CSB).

Their teaching was producing speculation rather than advancing God’s work. Timothy was not told to wait until everyone agreed that the teaching was harmful. He was told to address it.

Paul later wrote:
“Command and teach these things.”
—1 Timothy 4:11, CSB


The following verse matters:
“Don’t let anyone despise your youth.”
—1 Timothy 4:12, CSB


Timothy would lead people who were older, established, outspoken, or unimpressed by him. Paul did not tell him to compensate with arrogance. He told him to set an example in speech, conduct, love, faith, and purity.

Character was to strengthen Timothy’s authority, not replace its exercise.

Paul also gave Timothy a careful framework for dealing with age and office. He was to exhort an older man as a father rather than lash out at him (1 Timothy 5:1). He was not to accept an accusation against an elder without adequate witnesses (1 Timothy 5:19).

Due process mattered. Honor mattered. Evidence mattered.

​But once persistent sin was established, Paul said:

“Publicly rebuke those who sin.”
—1 Timothy 5:20, CSB


He then charged Timothy to act without prejudice or favoritism. The pastoral response was neither impulsive nor timid. It was careful, impartial, and clear.

Some pastors make an initial appeal, receive a forceful response, and decide they have done enough. Paul prepared Timothy for people who would not respond to the first pass. In his final letter, he charged him:

“Preach the word; be ready in season and out of season; correct, rebuke, and encourage.”
—2 Timothy 4:2, CSB


The command includes patience and teaching, but it still includes correction and rebuke.
  • A patient rebuke is still a rebuke.
  • A loving correction is still a correction.

Titus Was Told to Silence What Was Destroying Households
​

Titus faced a difficult assignment in Crete. Paul described rebellious people, empty talkers, and deceivers. They were disrupting entire households with teaching they should not spread. His directive was not vague: they “must be silenced” (Titus 1:11, CSB).

Paul then told Titus:
“Rebuke them sharply, so that they may be sound in the faith.”
—Titus 1:13, CSB


Notice the purpose.
The rebuke was not punishment for irritating the pastor. It was not the discharge of a leader’s anger. It was corrective and restorative: “so that they may be sound in the faith.”

Later Paul wrote:
“Proclaim these things; encourage and rebuke with all authority. Let no one disregard you.”
—Titus 2:15, CSB


Titus was not to surrender his pastoral responsibility to the loudest critic in the room.

Paul also established a limit:
“Reject a divisive person after a first and second warning.”
—Titus 3:10, CSB


That is not conflict avoidance. It is a deliberate process: warn clearly, warn again, and then act.
The divisive person does not receive unlimited opportunities to damage the body while the pastor keeps scheduling conversations that produce no repentance.

This is where many conflict-resistant pastors need courage. Some people will not respond to a hint. Some will interpret gentleness as uncertainty. Some will use every delay to recruit allies, spread suspicion, and strengthen their position.
A shepherd must know when patient instruction has been rejected and firmer action is required.

Full Rebuke Does Not Mean Fleshly Leadership
The New Testament does not authorize a pastor to become quarrelsome. In the same letters that command correction, Paul writes that the Lord’s servant “must not quarrel” but must be gentle, able to teach, and patient, “instructing his opponents with gentleness” (2 Timothy 2:24–25, CSB).

That is the balance:
  • Do not quarrel, but do confront.
  • Be gentle, but do not be vague.
  • Be patient, but do not be passive.
  • Honor older members, but do not surrender biblical responsibility to seniority.
  • Give warnings, but do not permit endless disruption.
  • Rebuke with authority, but never with ego, retaliation, or cruelty.

A full and faithful rebuke names the conduct, explains the biblical concern, describes the harm, calls for repentance, identifies the necessary change, and states what will happen if the behavior continues. It is direct enough to be understood and measured enough to be just.

Before the conversation, get the facts. Pray. Examine your motives.

Determine whether the issue is sin, doctrine, mission, or simply your preference. Follow the church’s governing documents and the biblical process. When possible, bring appropriate witnesses or leaders.


Speak to the person, not around the person.

Document what was decided. Establish a clear time for follow-up. If there is repentance, pursue restoration. If disruption continues, follow through.

The goal is never to win a fight. The goal is to guard the church, recover the person where possible, restore soundness, and keep the gospel mission from being derailed.

Pastor, Take the Next Faithful Step
If you are conflict resistant, courage may not feel natural. That does not disqualify you.
Courage is not the absence of anxiety. It is obedience in the presence of it.

You may be younger than the person you must address. You may be less forceful. They may have more history, money, relatives, influence, or confidence. They may dismiss the first conversation, question your motives, or dare you to act.

Your authority does not come from being louder. It comes from the Word you are responsible to teach, the character you are called to display, and the pastoral stewardship Christ has entrusted to you.

Do not manufacture conflict. Do not pursue every argument. Do not confuse your preferences with biblical conviction.
But when doctrine is distorted, people are harmed, sin persists, or division spreads, do not hide behind a counterfeit peace.

Walk toward the conflict.

Tell the truth. Make the appeal. Give the warning. Correct patiently. Rebuke faithfully. Follow through courageously. Protect the congregation Christ has placed in your care, and clear the way for the mission He has given His church.
Sometimes the most loving thing a pastor can say is, “This must stop.”
​

Scripture quotations are from the Christian Standard Bible (CSB), copyright © 2017 by Holman Bible Publishers. Used by permission.

​
0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Archives

    July 2026
    June 2026
    May 2026
    April 2026
    March 2026
    February 2026
    November 2025
    October 2025
    August 2025
    July 2025
    June 2025
    May 2025
    February 2025
    December 2024
    November 2024
    October 2024
    August 2024
    July 2024
    June 2024
    May 2024

    Categories

    All
    Church Life
    Church Renewal
    Following Jesus
    Fun
    LEADERSHIP
    Throwback

    RSS Feed

  • Home
  • Blog
  • About
  • Resources
  • Contact